What it is
An approach where multiple designers independently create solutions to the same brief at the same time, without conferring, so the team can compare genuinely different directions before converging.
When to use it
During Ideate, when you want breadth and to avoid premature convergence on one person’s idea.
Why (value)
Produces more-diverse solutions than collaborative-from-the-start work, reduces anchoring, and gives real alternatives to evaluate.
How to run it
- Give everyone the same brief and constraints.
- Have each design independently, without sharing early.
- Bring the solutions together to compare.
- Extract the strongest elements from each.
- Converge on a combined direction.
Inputs and outputs
- Inputs: A shared brief and multiple designers.
- Outputs: Several independent design directions to compare and merge.
Time and effort
Medium. Parallel effort plus a comparison session.
Evidence and limitations
Generates alternatives, not validation. Compare and then test the chosen direction. See Evidence and limitations.
Tips and pitfalls
- Keep the independent phase truly independent.
- Use identical briefs so comparison is fair.
- Harvest the best of each rather than picking one wholesale.
Variations
Parallel prototyping, competitive internal design.
Related methods
Need help choosing and applying a method?
Gumshoe helps teams connect research, collaborative workshops and service design to the decisions they need to make.
Sources and further reading
- UX Tigers, “100 UX methods.”
Explore related methods
- Design studio — A structured sketch-critique-iterate workshop that gets a cross-functional group designing together.
- Crazy eights — Sketch eight ideas in eight minutes to force quantity and break fixation.
- Design critique — Gather peers to give structured, goal-focused feedback on work in progress.
