Gumshoe · Method reference

Design critique

Gather peers to give structured, goal-focused feedback on work in progress.

Conceptual illustration of design critique.
Effort
Low
Participants
Not required
Remote friendly
Yes
Evidence / output
Expert review

What it is

A facilitated session where designers present work and peers give focused, constructive feedback against the design’s stated goals rather than personal preference.

When to use it

During Ideate and Prototype, at regular intervals while design is still malleable.

Why (value)

Improves work through diverse perspectives, catches issues early, and builds shared standards across a team.

How to run it

  1. Presenter states goals, context, and the feedback they want.
  2. Participants ask clarifying questions first.
  3. Give feedback tied to goals, not taste.
  4. Capture themes and action items.
  5. Presenter decides what to act on.

Inputs and outputs

  • Inputs: Work in progress, stated goals, a small group of peers.
  • Outputs: Focused feedback and a short list of actions.

Time and effort

Low. 30 to 60 minutes.

Evidence and limitations

Produces expert-review peer judgment, not direct-user evidence; it improves craft and alignment but cannot confirm what users will do. See Evidence and limitations.

Tips and pitfalls

  • Critique against goals, not personal style.
  • Separate clarifying questions from reactions.
  • Keep it safe and constructive, not a status review.

Variations

Formal crit, design jam feedback, and asynchronous written critique.

Need help choosing and applying a method?

Gumshoe helps teams connect research, collaborative workshops and service design to the decisions they need to make.

Discuss your project with Gumshoe Explore Gumshoe services

Sources and further reading

Explore related methods

  • Design review — Formally review a design against requirements, standards, and stakeholder expectations before it advances.
  • Design pairing — Two people design together in real time, combining perspectives and catching issues early.
  • Expert review — Have an experienced UX practitioner assess a design and report likely problems and fixes.

A general practice reference. This page does not establish that a method was used on a particular client project or that an outcome was measured.