What it is
A holistic evaluation in which a seasoned UX expert examines an interface drawing on experience, heuristics, and best practice, then reports problems and recommendations.
When to use it
During Prototype or Implement, for a fast, broad read when user testing is not feasible or as a precursor to it.
Why (value)
Leverages pattern knowledge to surface likely issues quickly and cheaply across the whole experience.
How to run it
- Agree on scope, goals, and user context.
- Have the expert walk key flows critically.
- Document issues with rationale and severity.
- Recommend concrete fixes.
- Review findings with the team.
Inputs and outputs
- Inputs: The design, context and goals, an experienced evaluator.
- Outputs: A prioritized findings and recommendations report.
Time and effort
Low. A day or less for most reviews.
Evidence and limitations
Produces expert-review evidence shaped by the reviewer’s judgment; it is not direct-user validation and quality varies with the expert. Label it clearly as expert opinion. See Evidence and limitations.
Tips and pitfalls
- Ground findings in principles, not personal taste.
- State severity and rationale for each issue.
- Validate high-stakes findings with users.
Variations
Heuristic-structured, free-form holistic, and persona-based review.
Related methods
Need help choosing and applying a method?
Gumshoe helps teams connect research, collaborative workshops and service design to the decisions they need to make.
Sources and further reading
Explore related methods
- Heuristic evaluation — Have evaluators inspect an interface against usability principles to catch problems fast.
- Cognitive walkthrough — Step through a task as a new user would, asking at each step whether they could figure out what to do.
- Design review — Formally review a design against requirements, standards, and stakeholder expectations before it advances.
