Gumshoe · Method reference

Severity ratings

Rate usability problems by impact so teams fix the most damaging issues first.

Conceptual illustration of severity ratings.
Effort
Low
Participants
Not required
Remote friendly
Yes
Evidence / output
Expert review

What it is

A scale (often frequency, impact, and persistence combined) applied to usability findings to prioritize which problems to fix first, commonly used to triage the output of usability testing or expert reviews.

When to use it

During Synthesize of evaluation results and into Implement for triage, after usability testing or heuristic evaluation.

Why (value)

Turns a flat list of problems into an actionable priority order and helps negotiate fixes against effort and risk.

How to run it

  1. Collect the usability findings.
  2. Rate each on impact, frequency, and persistence.
  3. Combine into an overall severity level.
  4. Optionally calibrate ratings with a second evaluator.
  5. Prioritize fixes by severity against effort.

Inputs and outputs

  • Inputs: A list of usability findings from testing or review.
  • Outputs: Severity-ranked issues to guide prioritization.

Time and effort

Low. A short pass over existing findings.

Evidence and limitations

Severity is an expert judgment layered on findings; ratings vary between evaluators, so calibrate and treat them as informed estimates, not measured facts. See Evidence and limitations.

Tips and pitfalls

  • Use a consistent, defined scale.
  • Have more than one person rate to reduce bias.
  • Combine severity with effort to prioritize realistically.

Variations

Nielsen’s severity scale, frequency-impact-persistence scoring.

Need help choosing and applying a method?

Gumshoe helps teams connect research, collaborative workshops and service design to the decisions they need to make.

Discuss your project with Gumshoe Explore Gumshoe services

Sources and further reading

Explore related methods

  • Heuristic evaluation — Have evaluators inspect an interface against usability principles to catch problems fast.
  • Usability testing — Watch representative users attempt real tasks to find where the design helps or gets in their way.
  • Impact-effort prioritization — Plot options by impact and effort to spot the quick wins and avoid the money pits.

A general practice reference. This page does not establish that a method was used on a particular client project or that an outcome was measured.