What it is
A structured review of competitor and analogous products against a set of criteria, documenting how others solve the problem and where openings exist.
When to use it
During Initiate or Immerse, to set context, learn established patterns, and spot differentiation opportunities.
Why (value)
Grounds strategy in the real landscape, prevents reinventing solved problems, and reveals conventions users already expect.
How to run it
- Pick direct and indirect comparators.
- Define evaluation criteria tied to your goals.
- Walk key flows and capture evidence.
- Compare side by side across criteria.
- Summarize gaps, risks, and opportunities.
Inputs and outputs
- Inputs: A comparator set, criteria, access to the products.
- Outputs: A comparison matrix, screenshots, and opportunity notes.
Time and effort
Medium. A few days depending on breadth and depth.
Evidence and limitations
Produces expert-review evidence about the market, not direct-user validation; competitors may be wrong, so do not treat parity as proof of goodness. See Evidence and limitations.
Tips and pitfalls
- Tie criteria to user goals, not feature checklists.
- Include indirect and analogous products.
- Avoid copying competitor mistakes as if validated.
Variations
Feature comparison, heuristic-style competitive teardown, and pattern benchmarking.
Related methods
Need help choosing and applying a method?
Gumshoe helps teams connect research, collaborative workshops and service design to the decisions they need to make.
Sources and further reading
- UX Tigers, “100 UX methods.”
- 18F Methods (US government, public domain).
Explore related methods
- Comparative analysis — Compare products or features against each other, including from outside your domain, to learn and set direction.
- Content audit — Inventory and assess existing content to see what you have, what works, and what must change.
- Heuristic evaluation — Have evaluators inspect an interface against usability principles to catch problems fast.
